Skip to main content

Germany’s prostitution law goes back to the drawing board — what to watch in November

An expert commission delivers proposals to reform Germany’s Prostitute Protection Act at the end of November 2026, as senior CDU and CSU politicians push for a ban on buying sex. What the official evaluation actually found, the options on the table, and why platform rules may matter most.

EscortFox editorial

· 9 min read
sources cited

Why this is coming to a head now

Germany recognised sex work as a legal occupation in 2002 and has regulated it through the Prostitute Protection Act (Prostituiertenschutzgesetz, ProstSchG) since July 2017. That law is now under formal review. An independent expert commission set up by the federal family ministry is due to deliver its proposals for legislative change at the end of November 2026, with non-legislative proposals and a final report to follow by the end of May 2027.

The political pressure ahead of that deadline comes almost entirely from one side. On 5 October, Bavaria’s social minister Ulrike Scharf (CSU) said that clients should be punished, after visiting Sweden in September to study its ban on buying sex. She summed it up as “Germany has to move on protecting prostitutes.” She follows two senior CDU figures. In early November 2025, Bundestag president Julia Klöckner told an award ceremony in Berlin that Germany must “finally ban prostitution and the purchase of sex”. Days later, federal health minister Nina Warken told the Rheinische Post that Germany “must no longer be the brothel of Europe”.

None of this is government policy yet. The CDU/CSU and SPD coalition could not agree on a ban when it was formed in 2025, and its coalition agreement says only that, in light of the evaluation, the law will be improved “where necessary”, with the support of an independent expert commission. Whether “where necessary” stays a repair job or becomes a change of model is what the next few months will decide.

What the 2025 evaluation actually found

The ProstSchG required its own evaluation. The Criminological Research Institute of Lower Saxony (KFN) carried it out between 2022 and 2025, and the ministry laid it before the Bundestag on 24 June 2025. It is the largest study of its kind in Germany: written surveys reached just over 2,300 sex workers, 3,400 clients, 800 officials and 280 operators of prostitution businesses.

Its headline verdict is more positive than the current debate suggests. The evaluators found clear signs that the law’s concrete aims were achieved to a considerable extent: the registration interview does inform people about their rights and health risks, working conditions in licensed businesses have improved, and the condom duty works at least in part. The law, in their words, has not failed.

The weaknesses they list are specific:

  • Registration reaches only part of the people it is meant for. The main reasons are an unwillingness to disclose the work to an authority and fear for the security of the stored registration data. Behind both, the evaluators found widespread experience of discrimination, to the point that many sex workers hide their work from close family. They call for state action against that stigma.
  • The bureaucratic threshold is too high for some, and some people are excluded from registration, and from the support that comes with it, for immigration reasons.
  • Other interests shaped the law, notably the tax administration’s interest in making sex workers easier to tax, which the evaluators say runs against the law’s protective purpose.
  • Enforcement is uneven. A considerable share of the officials responsible have had no specific training. In some states small municipalities handle only a few cases each, and the registration process rarely identifies victims of trafficking or exploitation, which was one of its stated purposes.
  • Arranging sex work is moving online, and the evaluators suggest considering regulation of that space too, in particular the so-called prostitution platforms. More on that below.

Registration figures fit that picture. According to the Federal Statistical Office, 32,474 people held a valid registration at the end of 2025, up 0.7% on a year earlier but well below the 40,400 registered at the end of 2019. Those figures count registrations, not the number of people doing sex work; no reliable estimate of that total exists, which the evaluators themselves point out.

The commission and its critics

The commission first met on 24 November 2025. It has twelve members, drawn from anti-trafficking work, academia, prosecution, criminal justice, platform regulation, social work and health, and it is chaired by Professor Tillmann Bartsch, who also led the evaluation. The ministry lists its focus areas as prostitution in the digital space and how to regulate it, vulnerable groups such as people who use drugs, homeless people and young adults, and other regulatory models, including the so-called Nordic model.

Both camps object to its make-up. The Bundesverband Nordisches Modell, which campaigns for a ban on buying sex, criticised on the day it was set up that no women who have left prostitution sit on it, and that the evaluation’s author chairs it. From the other side, the Bundesverband Sexuelle Dienstleistungen, an association of the legal sex industry, objects that sex workers, clients and operators are not members, and can only answer written questions. A commission criticised from both directions is not proof of balance, but neither side can claim it was built to deliver their outcome.

Three directions the proposals could take

Broadly, the November proposals can go one of three ways, or combine them.

  • Repair the ProstSchG. This is where the evaluation points: a lower-threshold registration process, better-trained and more centralised authorities, a registration interview built around informed choice, and decoupling protection from tax collection. It keeps Germany’s legal model and fixes what the evidence says is broken.
  • Switch to the Nordic model. Buying sex becomes a crime, selling it does not. Sweden introduced this in 1999, and Norway, Iceland, France and Ireland followed. In 2024 the European Court of Human Rights held, in M.A. and Others v. France, that France’s version does not violate the Convention, so the question in Germany is political, not legal. It is also the option the evaluation gives the least support to, since its findings describe a law that mostly works and can be fixed.
  • Regulate the platforms. This is the least discussed option, and probably the one most likely to appear in some form whichever model wins.

The platform question

The ProstSchG licenses four kinds of prostitution business: premises, vehicles, events and agencies that arrange bookings (Prostitutionsvermittlung). A website on which providers advertise their own services, and which does not arrange the booking, fits none of the four. Online advertising is regulated only through the content rules in § 32: it is an offence to advertise sex without a condom, sex with pregnant women, or in a way that endangers the protection of minors.

The evaluators note that the arranging of sex work is moving “into the digital”, and suggest considering regulation of that space. In the same passage they raise the other side of it: the more contact moves online, the harder it becomes for specialist counselling services to reach the people they exist to help. Among the evaluation’s recommendations, as summarised by the City of Wiesbaden’s women’s office, is bringing the platforms into the licensing procedure.

Platform regulation can mean very different things. It can mean licensing, identity checks on advertisers and duties to remove illegal content, the model Germany already applies to brothels and agencies. It can also mean requiring every advertiser to show a valid registration certificate, or holding platforms liable for anything their advertisers do. These lead to very different outcomes, and the difference matters most for the many people who work outside registration today.

Our view

EscortFox is a classifieds directory. Providers advertise their own services on it; we do not arrange bookings and take no share of what anyone earns. Platform rules are therefore the part of this debate that applies to us directly, and we would rather say what we think before the proposals are published than react afterwards.

We would welcome rules that make the things responsible directories already do a legal minimum. On EscortFox every new listing is reviewed before it goes live, a listing’s phone number has to be confirmed with a one-time code before it can be published, providers can have their photos verified, and anyone can report non-consensual or underage imagery or impersonation through a public removal form. Licensing platforms on those terms, and enforcing the existing § 32 advertising rules against those who ignore them, would raise the floor without pushing anyone out.

What we would argue against is turning platforms into the enforcement arm of registration. The evaluation found that most of the people registration misses stay away because they fear disclosure and doubt their data is safe. A rule that bars them from moderated, accountable directories will not bring them into the system. It will push them onto sites hosted abroad, onto messaging apps and onto the street, where nobody verifies anything and where, as the evaluators warn, counselling services cannot follow.

The evaluation offers Germany an evidence-based way to make its law work better. Whatever the commission proposes in November, it should be measured against that evidence and against the experience of the people the law is meant to protect. Support organisations, legal aid and anonymous testing in Germany and across Europe are listed in our guide Sex-worker support in Europe; the current German rules are explained in Das Prostituiertenschutzgesetz (ProstSchG) erklärt.

Share

EscortFox editorial

Written by the EscortFox editorial team. We cite primary sources — judgments, statutes, official bodies — and link the coverage we drew on. Quote and link freely.